New Zealand has a sad history of decisions that sacrifice long-term strategic value for short-term commercial or political gain. They may seem sensible, affordable or politically attractive at the time, only for us to understand decades later what we have lost.
The proposed closure of Kāpiti Airport may be another example.
In the 1870s, we opted for our narrow-gauge railway system: it was cheaper than a wider gauge and allowed us to build a national network quickly. There were sound short-term reasons for that decision, but the narrower gauge has imposed capacity and speed constraints that remain with us 150 years later, limiting rail’s potential as a core transport option.
A hundred years later, in 1975, Robert Muldoon’s Government abolished Labour’s compulsory contributory superannuation scheme. Had it survived, New Zealand would now have accumulated many hundreds of billions of dollars in retirement savings, reducing our dependence on overseas borrowings (and giving us a 17 year head-start on Australia’s much-admired scheme), also reducing the long-term burden of taxpayer-funded pensions.
We cannot know precisely what might have been. But both decisions show the folly of failing to look beyond the immediate costs (financial or political) in favour of long-term value and consequences.
Now we face another such decision.
Kāpiti Airport is scheduled to close on 30 November. Once it’s gone, it’s gone.
A strategic asset, not just a business
The airport’s owners argue that it is commercially unsustainable. They have entered into a conditional sale agreement requiring its closure.
I don’t dispute their right to seek a return on their investment. Property rights matter. But there is a fundamental difference between the commercial value of an asset to its owners and its strategic value to the wider community.
Kāpiti Airport serves one of the lower North Island’s fastest-growing population centres. It provides regional air connections, general aviation, pilot training, Air Ambulance and emergency aviation capacity. It also offers an alternative to Wellington Airport, with its notorious weather, geographic and operational constraints.
Close Kāpiti, and the coastal corridor between Wellington and Palmerston North loses its only operational airport.
The benefits of redevelopment are likely to accrue principally to the landowners. The costs of losing the airport will fall on the wider community, including the broader Wellington region, and on future generations.
Who has assessed those costs? And over what time horizon?
The vicious circle
For more than 25 years, uncertainty about the airport’s future has undermined confidence in its viability. It’s a circular argument:
- If airlines and other operators believe the airport may close, why invest in developing routes, building passenger numbers or establishing long-term operations?
- If customers cannot rely on continuing services, why build their travel habits around the airport?
- And if investment and passenger numbers decline, the airport becomes less commercially viable — providing further justification for closure.
Uncertainty discourages investment. Lack of investment weakens viability. Weak viability reinforces uncertainty.
Eventually, the outcome becomes almost self-fulfilling.
But … what if the airport had a clear, long-term commitment to remaining operational?
- What if airlines, aviation businesses and investors could plan with confidence over 20 or 30 years?
- Would we see new services, better facilities, more aviation businesses and a stronger commercial proposition – with the resulting growth in economic activity and employment in the region?
We cannot be certain. But surely that possibility deserves serious examination, before we permanently remove the option.
Private rights, public costs
The present owners acquired an operating airport. They knew its established use, its commercial constraints and its potential development value.
That does not oblige them to operate an airport indefinitely. Nor should private owners be expected to subsidise a public benefit without compensation.
But nor does ownership automatically confer the right to change an asset’s use without regard to the wider consequences.
Housing is important. So is regional infrastructure. This need not be an all-or-nothing choice.
Could part of the land be developed for housing while retaining a smaller, viable airport? Could public and private interests combine to secure the airport’s future? What would government support cost, compared with the long-term value of retaining the facility? And, not least, what about the interests of the three hāpu, the original owners of the airport land?
These are strategic questions requiring rigorous analysis, not simply a comparison of immediate commercial returns.
There is also the question of resilience. Wellington sits on a major fault line, with vulnerable road and rail connections. In a serious emergency, an operational airport north of the capital could prove invaluable.
We may not need that capacity tomorrow. But future generations may be very grateful that we preserved it.
The real test of strategy
Good governance requires us to distinguish between price and value, between short-term returns and long-term consequences.
We also need to recognise when decisions are irreversible.
We probably can’t change our railway gauge. We certainly can’t recover the 50 years of retirement savings we might have accumulated.
But, if we move fast, we still have an opportunity to reconsider the future of Kāpiti Airport.
Before allowing it to disappear, we should demand a proper assessment of its long-term strategic value, the alternatives to closure, and the consequences for generations to come.
The cheapest decision today may prove extraordinarily expensive tomorrow.
And once it’s gone, it’s gone.
_______
Declaration of Interest: I’ve lived on the Kāpiti Coast for many years. Friends and colleagues know I’m a life-long aviation geek, and I’m a Past President of the Kāpiti Aero Club.
